• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Taormina: Authentic New York Pizza & Italian Favorites in Paterson, NJ

Founded in 1981, Taormina is a family-owned gem in Paterson, NJ, where tradition and quality meet in every slice of pizza. Drawing from authentic Italian roots, this unpretentious eatery specializes in New York-style pizza, celebrated for its delightful chewiness and heavenly sauce that beautifully balances sweetness and acidity. Customers rave about the quality ingredients, like grande cheese, and the warm, inviting service that makes dining here a pleasure. With a focus on community and family, Taormina offers a casual, welcoming atmosphere perfect for groups and kids alike, making it a beloved local landmark for over four decades.

Taormina at a glance

  • Address 301 Madison Ave, Paterson, NJ 07524
  • Phone (973) 742-1163
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Taormina: Reviews & Ratings

Anika Anderson
5

I’ve been coming here since I was 5 years old. It’s still as great as when I had my first slice. I absolutely love this place and it’s my favorite pizza spot in all of Jersey. They’re always kind here and will have you in and out in no time!

Daisy Cortes
5

Taormina absolutely delivered. I tried the spinach wrap and a penne vodka slice with grilled chicken, and both were amazing. The flavors were on point, the chicken was perfectly grilled, and the penne vodka had that rich, creamy sauce you crave. And let’s talk about the cheese pull — unreal. Gooey, stretchy, and exactly how great pizza should be. Everything tasted fresh and made with care. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to when I want something satisfying and delicious. Highly recommend!

DJ Capone
5

Taromina Pizza in Paterson absolutely hits the spot! The cheese is just right, not too greasy and the crust? Perfection. Cooked to that ideal crisp without being overdone. I especially appreciate the sauce; it’s smooth and flavorful without that overpowering tang some places lean into. Every bite feels balanced and satisfying. My only gripe is the wait time. When I call in, I’m usually told 25 minutes, but realistically it’s closer to 35–45 mins. That being said, I keep coming back because it’s definitely worth the wait. If you’re craving pizza that nails the fundamentals, Taromina delivers!

Mauricio Navarro-Arias
5

I get pizza here sometimes, but I had never tried a pasta, today I did, and it is amazing!!! I just couldn't believe it, everything was cooked to perfection and of course,the flavor is incredible. I highly recommend this little hidden gem here in Paterson.

Marcela Lindo
4

I’m have been getting pizza here since my childhood. Hadn’t been in a while so decided to stop in for a slice. Still decently priced considering the economy. Got one plain slice and took it to go. Good service has always been my experience even when they are busy. There is space to sit inside. Has a small parking lot and there is street parking.

Trinibabe28
5

I was on a FB Marketplace journey and found myself hungry and far away from home. Checked google maps for restaurants and found this gem. I was in the mood for italian so I popped in. The staff was friendly and the food was great. Ordered a shrimp parm with linguini. Everything was so flavorful and the aroma wonderful. Cute local spot. I would definitely come back.

Jonathan Perez
5

Shoutout Marco, made me feel so welcomed. Food was great, Italian food is always good but this was an experience. By far best penne slice you can get. 5 STARS!!!!!

Marlen Adames
5

Taormina Pizzeria Italian Restaurant is my place to go for pizzas, lasagna and everything else. Their chicken and eggplant parm is the best I have ever tasted, including their garlic knots with the marinara sauce. Bottomline, no matter what you order from them is so delicious and you'll not be disappointed.

Location

  • Taormina
    Taormina
    301 Madison Ave, Paterson, NJ 07524 Hotline: (973) 742-1163

Welcome to Taormina, an establishment that exudes the charm and authenticity of Italian cuisine right in the heart of Paterson, NJ. Since its inception in 1981, Taormina has been lovingly operated by the same family, preserving traditional recipes that have stood the test of time. With its unpretentious atmosphere and a modest storefront, this pizzeria invites diners to experience the rich flavors of genuine New York-style pizza and other Italian favorites.

As you step into Taormina, you're greeted by the warm, bustling energy of its dedicated staff. The restaurant embodies a casual vibe, making it an ideal spot for group outings or family dinners. Here, patrons can enjoy the convenience of street parking, outdoor seating, and even Wi-Fi, ensuring that every visit is as comfortable as it is delicious.

  • Menu Highlights:
    • **Pizza:** Taormina's standout dish, known for its unique, thicker crust, offers a chewiness that pairs wonderfully with the rich, balanced tomato sauce. Toppings are artfully layered without overwhelming the palate, creating a harmonious experience with each bite.
    • **Starters:** Dive into their tantalizing appetizers like Buffalo wings, garlic knots, and mozzarella sticks, each crafted to complement your meal seamlessly.
    • **Other Delights:** Savor Italian classics such as meatballs and minestrone, designed to evoke a nostalgic taste of Italy.

Customer reviews reflect consistent satisfaction. One diner, Andrew C., lauded Taormina for using high-quality ingredients, specifically noting the greatness of their dough and grande cheese, while Debra P. appreciated the perfect balance of flavor in her plain cheese slices. The crust, a delightful blend of crispiness and structure, has earned glowing praise, establishing it as a signature of the restaurant.

Taormina is not just a meal; it’s an experience. Regulars like Patrick M. consider it a bucket-list destination, appreciating its history and familial roots. The sense of familiarity and community at Taormina amplifies the deliciousness of their offerings, making each visit feel less like dining out and more like returning home.

If you're in Paterson or just passing through, don't miss the chance to savor the flavors at Taormina. With a welcoming atmosphere, reasonable prices, and mouthwatering dishes, it's no surprise this establishment has become a beloved icon in the local culinary scene. Whether you're indulging in a classic pizza, sharing a plate of pasta with loved ones, or simply enjoying the vibrant ambiance, Taormina promises a dining experience that tantalizes the palate and warms the heart.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards